From the Jan Reimer Ladies (Team 8)

The Hate you Give vs. Optimists Die First

 

My reading journey this round began with Optimists Die First which my initial gut feeling wanted to declare it as a winner prior to finishing it. There were many chuckles as I read and related to the various cultural references (which I got perhaps more than a younger reader would), and most significantly to the over abundance of acquiring loveable fur balls (yes I do have three too many cats). Petula is not your average teen as she carries with her a major incident in her life that has made her weary of any and all life threatening ‘what ifs?’. I liked the quirkiness of her character and those around her as she tries to heal through group art therapy sessions. The topic of mental illness is again explored in this novel and in comparing it to many of my recent reads on the topic, this one handles it in a fun way, yet reminds the reader that everyone has a story to tell. Young love is also at the forefront of the plot as Petula develops a relationship with a ‘normal’ participant in therapy sessions. Petula’s journey begins similarly to mine as I began reading, optimistically looking forward to a fun read, but ends with an abrupt, all too quick finish after skillfully developing the plot. Unfortunately this left me disappointed and feeling like I was short changed in the optimism I originally experienced.

In this round the Optimist definitely dies.
I started this round with The Hate U Give and absolutely loved it. It captured my attention right from the beginning and I wanted to read on. Starr Carter’s voice was compelling and took me on an emotional roller coaster. One moment I was laughing out loud at the references (Fresh Prince of Bel Air anyone?) and the next moment I was twisted in knots as the scene unfolded. There are many layers to this story: the complexities of friendship and family dynamics, navigating your way through your first romantic relationship, the courage it takes to have your voice heard, the stereotypes based on socioeconomic status, and of course, racism and police violence. Regardless of what was unfolding in the story, Starr’s voice was able to draw you in and you felt like you were part of what was taking place. Starr’s incredible journey through shock, pain, courage and hope definitely comes out on top during Round Two.