Dan vs. Nature is up against Paper Girls.

OK.  Some people think graphic novels are books.   I get the argument, but really, it is a comic.  It is a series of pictures (well drawn), with minimal text.   The reader does not have the joy of creating their own mind's images.  Actual reading is limited to afew sentences (at most) on each page.  That alone bodes ill for this book in the smackdown competition.  Couple that with word choice that has too much f*&king swearing (did I offend anyone?  I am trying to make a point.) and again, Paper Girls did not impress our reading team.

Paper Girls came in a close second to "Dan vs. Nature".   Get it?  Choosing Dan vs. Nature, is like choosing liver over kidney.   If you like scatological humor, and extended fart jokes, read on.  The legal definition of torture has been much debated in recent media, and I take "Dan vs. Nature" to be a useful contribution to the debate.

The winner:   Dan vs. Nature.    Like liver over kidney.